ICH Q9(R1) — Quality Risk Management · vICH Q9(R1) (2023)

ICH Q9(R1) — Quality Risk Management

ICH Q9(R1) — Quality Risk Management — 75% covered.

4 requirements · 3 enforced · 0 designed · 0 advisory · 0 deferred.

Source: ICH Q9(R1) Quality Risk Management provides principles and tools for a systematic process for the assessment, control, communication and review of risks to the quality of a medicinal product across its lifecycle. It anchors risk-based decision-making (formality of the risk assessment, subjectivity of risk decisions, and the role of risk in supply chain and product availability). KYE Protocol™ governs whether an AI-generated QRM output (a risk assessment, a risk-based decision, an FMEA record) may PROCEED to a consequential action — Quality-Unit approval, reliance in a dossier, or use to release a lot — under a named Quality Unit / QP authority, with the risk-decision justification recorded before the action and replay-provable provenance. KYE does not perform the risk science, set the risk thresholds, or judge whether the risk decision is correct. · License: ICH guidelines are published by the International Council for Harmonisation; KYE registry paraphrases each requirement's intent and cites the official identifier for mapping purposes only.

By category

CategoryReqsEnforcedDesignedAdvisoryDeferredCoverage
Risk-based decision authority at the action boundary 1 1 0 0 0 100%
Risk-decision justification recorded before the action 1 1 0 0 0 100%
Replay-provable QRM provenance 1 1 0 0 0 100%
Risk-assessment science & control-strategy selection 1 0 0 0 0 0%

Every requirement → the KYE artefact that enforces it

IDTitleStatusKYE enforcement
ich-q9.qrm-decision-authority Risk-based decision by an AI QRM output proceeds only under a recorded named-authority decision enforced audit_events: kye.purpose.request.v1, kye.purpose.admissibility.v1, kye.evidence.decision_map.v1
engines: internal, internal
rule_packs: kye:rule-pack:ich-authority
dictionaries: internal
constitution_refs: constitution/12-PURPOSE-PERMISSION.md
ich-q9.risk-decision-justification An AI risk-based decision proceeds only with its risk-decision justification recorded before the action enforced audit_events: kye.evidence.decision_map.v1, kye.evidence.pack.v1
engines: internal
rule_packs: kye:rule-pack:ich-authority
constitution_refs: constitution/13-RESILIENCE-LOOP.md
ich-q9.qrm-provenance Replay-provable provenance pin for an AI QRM output relied on in a consequential action enforced audit_events: kye.evidence.tool_call.v1, kye.replay.context_seal.v1
engines: internal
rule_packs: kye:rule-pack:ich-authority
constitution_refs: constitution/13-RESILIENCE-LOOP.md
ich-q9.risk-assessment-science Hazard identification, probability / severity scoring and control-strategy selection out-of-scope (no enforcement cited)